Collars Vs. Leashes for Dogs

We've all seen a dog owner with the sweet, obedient pet that never strays from his side during a walk. One might think that dogs intuitively know they should stay by their owner's side.



However, what many people discover when they get a dog for the first time is that going for walk, whether in the neighborhood, a downtown area, or a more natural setting, incites such excitement in the dog that the last thing he wants is to remain at his owner's side.



Many dog owners at this point consider whether an electronic dog collar or a more traditional leash is more appropriate. When making a decision, understanding the different functions of each helps.
  1. Electronic Dog Collar

    • Electronic dog collars use electronic signals to punish dogs for undesirable behavior. The Anti-Bark Collar, for example, delivers a small shock each time a dog barks, thus teaching that barking is undesirable. Electronic collars also are used to teach dogs to stay within a certain perimeter in the yard. Each time a dog attempts to leave the yard, the electronic collar delivers a series of shocks.

      Electronic collars and electronic leashes also are gaining popularity as a training device for keeping dogs nearby when going for a walk.

    Traditional Leashes

    • Traditional leashes vary in length, width, and are typically made of nylon, leather, or chain. Although traditional leashes do not electronically shock dogs when they misbehave, they generally give owners a measure of control over the dog that encourages a positive learning experience.

      When buying a traditional leash, consider whether a shorter leash for tighter control is more appropriate. Longer leashes allow more freedom and are suitable choices for well-behaved dogs.

    Electronic Collars versus Traditional Leashes

    • Electronic collars and leashes can be an effective means of dog training, they are potentially physically and psychologically harmful to dogs if incorrectly used. They also are considered a last resort training device. Consulting an expert and taking great care to correctly use an electronic collar helps ensure its success.

      Traditional leashes, on the other hand, are used by most dog trainers for training and walking dogs. Traditional leashes help dogs understand who is the leader of the pack, figuratively speaking. The absence of electronic shocks or punishment may also help create a stronger bond between dog owner and dog.

    Questions to ask When Making a Final Decision

    • Questions you might ask when deciding between an electronic dog collar or traditional leash:

      a. Am I comfortable with the idea of using an electronic shock collar on my pet?

      b. Do I think I might achieve the same results with a traditional collar as with an electronic shock collar?

      c. Am I willing to take the time to learn how to use a shock collar correctly?

      Finally, whether using an electronic collar or traditional leash, a calm manner, patience, and a persistent attitude are key to successfully training a dog.