What Are Better Alternatives Than Shock Collars for Dogs?

The use of shock collars has been a matter of controversy since their introduction approximately 30 years ago, and the debate does not seem to be ending anytime soon. Supporters of shock collars believe that the devices offer dog owners "peace of mind" when worn by a dog that cannot be kept under control by any other means or exhibits behavior that is inappropriate. But opponents stand firm against the use of shock collars, insisting that using shocks to subdue a pet is cruel and inhumane and should be replaced by positive reinforcement training that excludes the use of pain or force.

  1. The Citronella Alternative

    • Citronella collars follow the same idea as electric shock collars, but instead of sending out an electric shock to correct the behavior, a burst of citronella is emitted. Most dogs find the odor of citronella offensive and after a period of time will associate the behavior with the citronella and discontinue it.

    Ask Experts for Help

    • Investing in an animal behaviorist to work with you and your dog may be a better alternative to a shock collar. Animal behaviorists and trainers can offer techniques to deal with problems such as excessive barking and jumping, eliminating the need to use a shock collar.

    Try the Clicker

    • Clicker training is a method of training that involves a tiny hand-held device that makes an audible clicking sound when pressed. When your dog exhibits a problem behavior, click the device. The device will bring your dog to attention, stopping the behavior. If used consistently, the problem behavior can be eliminated.

    The Treat Incentive

    • Dogs that are highly "food motivated" will find that discontinuing an annoying behavior is worth it when the reward is a tasty treat. Gently disciplining your dog when he presents a bad behavior and offering him a treat when he displays appropriate behavior will keep him on the straight and narrow.

    The Outdoor Lead Alternative

    • A shock collar that is used to keep your dog within the boundaries of your property may fail when you least expect it. Some strong-willed dogs will decide to take the shock in exchange for a chance to prowl the neighborhood shock-free once they have surpassed the reach of the wireless fence. Investing in an outdoor lead, which is simply a long lead or leash attached to a steel spike buried in the ground, may be a better alternative.