Underground Dog Fence Alternative

Choosing an alternative to an underground dog fence depends on why you have one or are considering getting one. Some people do not like the looks of regular fencing, cannot afford it or live in places where normal fencing is not allowed. Tying a dog out is not safe, and it is illegal in some areas.

  1. Underground Fence Issues

    • Underground fences may keep your dog in. However, your dog may learn it can charge through and have the pain of a shock or citronella spray stop quickly. Many discover this when they get excited and go after an animal, kids on bikes or other enticements. Once out, your dog may not want to get "punished" by coming back in. If your dog injures anyone, in most states an underground fence is not considered evidence that the owner took reasonable precaution. Furthermore, underground fences will not keep people, other dogs and animals from coming to or harassing your dog. Failed batteries or poorly fitting collars also lead to containment failures. The best use of underground fencing is only when you are out with your dog.

    Portable Options

    • Depending on your dog's size, exercise pens and portable fencing may provide enough room to potty and exercise. Buying one that is easy to collapse but secure may be what your dog needs. For days when you cannot go out with the dog, a portable pen allows you flexibility.

    Kennel Run

    • If your objection to full fencing is looks or cost, a smaller kennel run is ideal. Even for a large dog, a run can be built---partially covered for protection from rain---at a reasonable cost while keeping most of your lawn open.

    Alternative Fencing

    • Smaller regular fencing in just a side or part of the backyard is about the same cost and is safer than underground fencing. Another option is the nearly invisible fences made of polypropylene plastic. This fencing is much cheaper than regular chain-link or privacy fences.

    Togetherness

    • Your dog needs to be outside for exercise and to potty. But you can build a bond with your dog, get exercise yourself and have a healthier, happier dog if you go out together. Options are simply walking or jogging with your dog, or even teaching it to follow you on a bike. Taking your dog to a park with a long line so you can play fetch or Frisbee, or finding a dog park in your area for regular play gives variety. For even more involvement, consider joining a local canine obedience group, flyball, tracking or agility. There are also dog sports for herding, carting and lure coursing.