Here's why:
* Different Measurement Methods: Size can be measured by weight, antler spread, or even body length. Each method produces different "winners."
* Unverified Claims: Many stories of exceptionally large deer are passed down through generations or shared online, but often lack official documentation or verification.
* Timeframe: Records of the largest deer might be incomplete or only reflect certain periods in history.
However, here are some notable examples of large deer that have been documented:
* The "Monarch" - A whitetail buck killed in Ohio in 1981 is often cited as the "world record" for its 30-point antlers with a 32.5-inch spread. However, this is not an official record recognized by any major organization.
* The "Texas Giant" - A whitetail buck shot in Texas in 2012 had a 32-inch antler spread, making it one of the largest recorded in the US.
* The "Canadian Moose" - While not technically in the US, a massive moose killed in Canada in 1997 weighed over 1,800 pounds.
Ultimately, the title of "biggest deer ever killed in the US" is subjective and depends on how size is defined.