- White-tailed deer
- Moose
- Black bear
- Coyote
- Red fox
- Grey wolf
- North American beaver
- Muskrat
- Raccoon
- Eastern chipmunk
- Red squirrel
- Southern flying squirrel
- Woodchuck
- Canada lynx
- Eastern cougar
Birds:
- Bald eagle
- Golden eagle
- American kestrel
- Merlin
- Peregrine falcon
- Northern goshawk
- Cooper's hawk
- Red-tailed hawk
- Swainson's hawk
- Broad-winged hawk
- Rough-legged hawk
- American crow
- Common raven
- Blue jay
- American robin
- Eastern bluebird
- Wood thrush
- American redstart
- Ovenbird
- Northern waterthrush
- Mourning warbler
- Common yellowthroat
- American goldfinch
- Eastern towhee
- Rose-breasted grosbeak
- Indigo bunting
- Scarlet tanager
- Northern cardinal
- Dickcissel
- Bobolink
- Red-winged blackbird
- Eastern meadowlark
- Common grackle
- Brown-headed cowbird
- Orchard oriole
- Baltimore oriole
Reptiles:
- Eastern garter snake
- Common snapping turtle
- Eastern box turtle
- Northern map turtle
- Painted turtle
- Milk snake
- Eastern ratsnake
- Northern water snake
- Eastern massasauga rattlesnake
Amphibians:
- American toad
- Fowler's toad
- Wood frog
- Spring peeper
- Gray tree frog
- Bullfrog
- Green frog
- Northern leopard frog
- Pickerel frog
Fish:
- Atlantic salmon
- Brook trout
- Brown trout
- Rainbow trout
- Lake trout
- Chinook salmon
- Coho salmon
- Walleye
- Yellow perch
- Largemouth bass
- Smallmouth bass
- Northern pike
- Muskellunge
- Catfish
- Whitefish
- Smelt
- Alewife
- Blueback herring
- Striped bass
- American eel
- Atlantic sturgeon
- Shortnose sturgeon
Invertebrates:
- Earthworms
- Insects (such as ants, beetles, bees, butterflies, flies, moths, and spiders)
- Snails
- Clams
- Crayfish
- Millipedes
- Centipedes